Last Updated on July 14, 2022 by The Health Master
Chennai, The Madras High Court has declined to restrain Sun Pharmaceuticals Industries Limited in Nandanam from using the word ‘Respules‘ in its business operations.
Justice Senthilkumar Ramamoorthy gave an interim ruling to this effect while disposing of three interlocutory applications arising out of a civil suit from Cipla Limited in Alapakkam here and in Mumbai, recently.
The first application: It sought to restrain Sun Pharmaceuticals, their partners or proprietors, servants, agents, stockists, distributors, wholesalers, retailers, and printers, and all persons acting through or under its direction from reproducing, printing, or publishing any label or packaging, including cartons, tubes, and caps for the purpose of export, which are a colorable imitation or substantial reproduction of the applicant’s subject products: “Budecort Respules’ and “Doulin Respules’.
The second application: It sought to restrain the firm from dealing in medicinal products or goods of any description bearing the mark ‘Respule’ and/or any other marks that are identical or deceptively similar to the applicant’s registered trademark ‘Respule‘ or containing any component of the subject trademark, amounting to infringement of the applicant’s registered trademark number 1127296.
The third application: It sought to restrain Sun Pharmaceuticals from dealing in medicinal products or goods of any description, using a packaging identical, or deceptively similar to the applicant’s packaging for ‘Budesonide Respules’ and ‘Doulin Levosalbutamol Respules’.
Passing interim orders, the judge said the evidence on record indicates prima facie that the word ‘Respules’ is used both by other manufacturers and by authorities such as the Director General of Health Services and the Drug Controller.
On examining the usage of the word by the aforesaid entities or authorities, it appears prima facie that ‘Respules’ has been used to describe a form in which the medicine is marketed.
In other words, the word has been used for medicines contained in capsules in liquid form, which are intended for injection into a nebulizer and used in the treatment of respiratory ailments.
Indeed, as correctly pointed out by Cipla, even the applicant has used the word ‘Respules’ in its advertisements as referring to a form in which the medicine is marketed.
As discussed above, the word ‘Respules’ is not self-evidently derived from the word “respiratory capsules.” At the same time, it is not as difficult to discern the constituent descriptive words.
“From a balance of convenience and hardship perspective, when the above aspect is reckoned in the context of the fairly common use of the word ‘RESPULES’ to refer to a form of medicine (including by the applicant companies in the advertisements) used to treat respiratory conditions, for interlocutory purposes, I am not inclined to restrain the respondent (Sun Pharmaceuticals) from using the word ‘RESPULES’.”
“The use of the lower case also does not tilt the balance in favor of the applicant companies,” the judge said.
The judge, however, directed Sun Pharmaceuticals to maintain accounts of revenues earned by the sale of products using the words “Respules,” including the profits derived therefrom.
Such accounts shall be filed with the court on a quarterly basis until the final disposal of the suit.
The question as to whether ‘Respules’ is distinctive and capable of protection as a trademark may be framed as one of the issues in the suit, the judge said.
USFDA considers to okay Over-The-Counter Birth Control Pill
Drug recall: Insulin Glargine Injection Pens recalled due to this reason
USFDA gives final nod for Type 2 Diabetes drug
USFDA issues Form 483 to Pharma Companies: Let’s know all about it
Medical Education Policy is required in India for students returning from abroad
Draft of Drugs, Medical Devices and Cosmetics Bill 2022: Could be a Game Changer ?
Medical device park to be developed: Govt will give these 7 exemptions to companies
Govt to focus on Pharmaceutical Research Policy
DCGI classifies 70 Medical Devices pertaining to Rehabilitation
Latest Notifications regarding Pharmaceuticals
For informative videos on the news regarding Pharma / Medical Devices / Cosmetics / Homoeopathy etc., click on the below YouTube icon:
For informative videos by The Health Master, click on the below YouTube icon:
For informative videos on Medical Store / Pharmacy, click on the below YouTube icon:
For informative videos on the news regarding Pharma / Medical Devices / Cosmetics / Homoeopathy etc., click on the below YouTube icon:
For informative videos on consumer awareness, click on the below YouTube icon:
